Common Pitfalls & Blind Spots
- Confusing a lower monthly payment caused by re-extending the loan tenor with genuine interest savings.
- Refinancing before the lock-in period ends without subtracting early-redemption penalties and rebate clawbacks.
- Comparing personal loan monthly flat rates (such as 0.20%/mo) directly against reducing-balance mortgage rates.
Separating Day-One Cash from 2-Year & 3-Year Net Gain
On an outstanding balance of HK$3,800,000 with 24 years remaining, switching from 3.85% to 3.40% with a 0.8% rebate (HK$30,400) and HK$6,500 legal costs yields HK$23,900 net day-one cash plus roughly HK$33,736 in two-year interest savings, totaling HK$57,636 net benefit. Triggering a 1% lock-in penalty (HK$38,000) and a HK$20,000 rebate clawback turns that into a HK$364 net loss.
Why a 0.20% Monthly Flat Rate Equals ~4.64% APR
The loan tool takes an annual flat rate: enter 2.4% for 0.20% monthly; over 24 months the effective annual rate is about 4.64%. The model excludes extra fees. Compare actual offers using all fees and repayment terms.
Eliminating Revolving Credit Card Interest First
Card rates, minimum-payment rules and new spending affect payoff time. Compare minimum and fixed repayments using the actual statement; no ten-year payoff claim is justified without those inputs.
Worked Comparison Table
2-Year Refinancing Outcome on HK$3,800,000 (24 Yrs Kept, 3.85% -> 3.40%)
People, scenarios and case studies are fictional. Amounts, rates, returns and fees are illustrative assumptions, not real cases, live quotations or guaranteed outcomes. Laws and formulas are explained using the cited sources; check actual inputs and applicable conditions.
| Scenario | New Rebate | Legal + Penalty / Clawback | 2-Yr Interest Saved | 2-Yr Net Gain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| After Lock-In Expiry | +HK$30,400 | -HK$6,500 | +HK$33,736 | +HK$57,636 |
| Inside Lock-In (1% Penalty + Clawback) | +HK$30,400 | -HK$64,500 | +HK$33,736 | -HK$364 |
Frequently Asked Questions
- Why can total interest rise even when the new mortgage rate is slightly lower?
- Resetting a 20-year remaining loan back to 30 years adds 10 extra years of interest accrual on the principal.
- Which metric compares a personal loan fairly against mortgage equity release?
- Compare the all-in Annual Percentage Rate (APR) including handling fees alongside total interest over the same payoff horizon.
